/ Resonance Index / Reply All (Defunct 2022)

Reply All (Defunct 2022)

Defunct Narrative Journalism · Gimlet (Spotify-owned)
F

Critical (F) — Resonance Grade

Reply All was the category-defining internet-culture narrative journalism podcast. Concluded July 2022 amid the Test Kitchen reporting controversy + Gimlet restructuring. Final season received critically.

18
Composite / 100
/ Subscore Breakdown · 5 Dimensions

Where this grade comes from.

Sonic Craft
F
Narrative Strength
F
Voice Performance
F
Production Value
F
Cultural Resonance
F
/ Key Events & Disclosures

Timeline & positioning.

  • Launched Nov 2014
  • Test Kitchen reporting controversy 2021
  • Concluded Jul 2022
  • Cautionary example of podcast-industry restructuring

/ Best for

Not relevant. Cautionary example.

/ Watch out for

Production concluded. Archive remains accessible but no new content. PJ Vogt's new Search Engine podcast is operational successor.